Luxury Waterfront
Living in the
Florida Keys
A curated guide to the most extraordinary waterfront properties, communities, and lifestyle the Islands of Florida have to offer.
Curated by The Florida Keys’
foremost authority.
Steve Conley is the Principal of the Conley Sales Group at COMPASS: the exclusive COMPASS office in the Florida Keys. With over three decades of experience and more than $1.4 billion in career sales, Steve brings a depth of local knowledge that simply cannot be replicated.
What sets Steve apart isn’t just the volume: it’s the expertise. As a licensed Sales Associate, Contractor, and Home Inspector, he evaluates properties with a trained eye that goes far beyond what a typical agent sees. He understands seawalls, dock construction, wind mitigation, flood zones, and the structural realities that determine a waterfront property’s true value.
Serving the entire island chain from Key Largo to Key West, with deep specialization in Key Largo, Tavernier, and Islamorada: Steve represents the definitive authority on luxury waterfront living in the Florida Keys.
Learn more about Steve
Sales
Group
Your Florida Keys
Luxury Authority.
Steve Conley is the Principal of the Conley Sales Group at COMPASS, the exclusive COMPASS office in the Florida Keys. With over 30 years of experience and more than $1.4 billion in career sales, Steve is the definitive authority on luxury waterfront living in the islands.
What truly sets Steve apart is the rare combination of a Florida state contractor’s license and a Florida state home inspector’s license, credentials that give him an unmatched ability to evaluate the structural integrity and true value of waterfront properties. Beyond surface-level aesthetics, he assesses seawall condition, dock construction, wind mitigation, and flood zone realities.
Serving the entire island chain from Key Largo to Key West, Steve specializes in Key Largo, Tavernier, and Islamorada while also representing properties in Marathon, Big Pine Key, and the Lower Keys. He is an AI 3.0 Certified Agent and a proud member of the Florida Keys Board of Realtors.
What Clients Say
Discerning buyers and sellers share their experience working with the Conley Sales Group.
“Steve and his son are consummate professionals. A lightning quick sale and amazing communication throughout the process.”
“We were impressed with the effective communication from the entire team at Steve Conley Realtor — COMPASS — Florida Keys, including the helpful realtor who guided us throughout the process. The clear and timely updates made our experience with their luxury real estate agency a seamless one.”
“Was a pleasure to work with. Steve made the transaction smooth with his knowledge and expertise. He was always available by phone or email. Would highly recommend.”
“Steve provided great communication to ensure a smooth process and keep the closing on track and closing on time. Thank you for everything!”
“We were thoroughly impressed with the exceptional level of service provided by Steve Conley Realtor — COMPASS — Florida Keys, from the knowledgeable and responsive listing agents to the seamless communication and efficient transaction process throughout our experience. Literally the Best agent in the key that I have worked with!”
“The most important thing to say about Steve is he will provide value to you!”
Reviews from Google Business Profile
The Florida Keys, island by island.
Each island community along the Overseas Highway carries its own rhythm, its own character, and its own definition of waterfront luxury.
Key Largo
Where the mainland meets The Florida Keys. World-class diving, deep-water access, and a vibrant waterfront dining scene: all within an hour of Miami.
Explore Key Largo
Tavernier
The sophisticated heart of the Upper Florida Keys. Tree-lined streets, intimate waterfront estates, and a pace that whispers rather than shouts.
Explore Tavernier Islamorada
Where competitive offshore fishing meets fine dining and gallery culture. A playground for those who appreciate the art of the catch.
Explore Islamorada
Marathon
A real community with deep-water marinas, whale watching, and the legendary Seven Mile Bridge. Full-time island living at its finest.
Explore Marathon
Big Pine Key
The wild heart of the Lower Florida Keys. Protected refuges, natural canals, and the kind of quiet that money usually can’t buy.
Explore Big Pine Key
World-class fishing.
Unrivaled boating.
The Florida Keys offer the finest saltwater fishing on the planet: from bonefish on the backcountry flats to blue marlin offshore. The boating culture here isn’t recreational; it’s existential. Properties with the right dock access, the right water depth, and the right exposure to open water don’t just command premiums: they define the lifestyle.
I help clients find properties that serve the way they actually live on the water.
Discover the LifestyleInsights, curated.
The Complete Florida Keys Waterfront Property Inspection Checklist
A comprehensive inspection checklist for Florida Keys waterfront properties, covering seawalls, docks, elevation, and wind mitigation from a licensed contractor's perspective.
Read More
Key Largo Luxury Waterfront: What $5 Million and Above Really Buys You
A detailed look at the Key Largo luxury waterfront market for high-net-worth buyers exploring $5M to $10M-plus waterfront estates.
Read More
Discovering Tavernier: The Quiet Luxury of the Upper Florida Keys
Tavernier offers sophisticated waterfront living, world-class fishing access, and a close-knit community that defines Upper Keys luxury at its most authentic.
Read More
Luxury Lifestyle Spotlight: Lazy Days Restaurant in Islamorada
Islamorada waterfront dining at a locally loved establishment with deep-water dock access.
Read More
The Pinnacle of Florida Keys Luxury: Notable Compass Sales
Exceptional high-end transactions that define the Florida Keys ultra-luxury market.
Read More
Inside the Florida Keys Ultra-Luxury Market
Pricing trends, buyer demographics, and strategic insights for high-net-worth buyers and sellers.
Read More
Exceptional Florida Keys Waterfront Properties
What defines a trophy waterfront property from deep-water access to architectural distinction.
Read MoreWhat discerning buyers
need to know.
Buying waterfront in The Florida Keys is unlike any other real estate transaction. These are the critical factors most agents miss: but a contractor and inspector never will.
Seawall & Dock
Your seawall and dock are as important as the home itself. Age, material, depth, and condition all affect value and insurability.
Open Water vs. Canal
Open-water properties command premium pricing and unobstructed views. Canal homes offer protection and calm-water dockage: each serves a different lifestyle.
Hurricane Preparedness
Wind mitigation, impact windows, elevated construction, and flood zone classification. With my contractor and inspector background, I evaluate what others overlook.
Insurance & HOA
Florida Keys insurance is its own specialty. HOA and ARCO rules govern dock use, renovations, and exterior modifications: I help you navigate them before you commit.
Your guide to luxury waterfront
real estate in the Florida Keys.
What makes the Florida Keys a luxury real estate market?
The Florida Keys are one of the most sought-after waterfront real estate markets in the world, defined by extreme scarcity of developable land, year-round tropical climate, world-class boating and fishing, and proximity to both Miami and the open Atlantic. Luxury properties here command premium pricing because there is a finite amount of waterfront land, and the demand from high-net-worth buyers continues to outpace supply. The market attracts discerning buyers seeking second homes, retirement estates, and trophy waterfront investments.
Where are the most expensive waterfront homes in the Florida Keys?
The most expensive waterfront homes are concentrated in Islamorada, known as the Sportfishing Capital of the World, where trophy estates on deep-water canals and open-water frontage command the highest per-square-foot prices in the Upper Keys. Key Largo also commands premium pricing for oceanfront and bayfront estates with direct access to the Atlantic. In the Middle Keys, Marathon offers deep-water properties, while Big Pine Key and the Lower Keys provide more secluded waterfront estates at comparatively accessible price points.
Who is Steve Conley and why should I work with him?
Steve Conley is the Principal of the Conley Sales Group at COMPASS, the exclusive COMPASS office in the Florida Keys. With over 30 years of experience and more than $1.4 billion in career sales, Steve holds the rare combination of Sales Associate, Contractor, and Home Inspector licenses. This trifecta gives him an unparalleled ability to evaluate waterfront properties beyond surface-level aesthetics. He assesses seawall condition, dock integrity, wind mitigation, flood zones, and structural factors that most agents cannot evaluate. For buyers and sellers in the luxury segment, this integrated expertise transforms a real estate transaction into a fully informed investment decision.
What types of luxury properties are available in the Florida Keys?
The Florida Keys luxury market offers a diverse range of property types including deep-water canal estates with private docks, open-water bayfront and oceanfront homes with unobstructed views, private island retreats, luxury condominiums in communities with controlled access, and sportfishing compounds with direct marina access. Each island from Key Largo to Key West has its own character: Key Largo offers mainland proximity, Islamorada delivers trophy sportfishing estates, Marathon provides full-time community amenities, and Big Pine Key offers secluded natural beauty. Steve Conley specializes in matching buyers with the right island and property type for their lifestyle.
Find your waterfront
in paradise.
Whether you’re seeking a private dock estate, a sportfishing basecamp, or a quiet canal retreat, Steve will guide you to the right property at the right price.
Conley Sales Group is a real estate Team affiliated with Compass. Compass Florida, LLC d/b/a Compass is a licensed real estate broker and abides by equal housing opportunity laws. All material presented herein is intended for informational purposes only. Information is compiled from sources deemed reliable but is subject to errors, omissions, changes in price, condition, sale, or withdrawal without notice. No statement is made as to accuracy of any description. All measurements and square footages are approximate. This is not intended to solicit property already listed. Nothing herein shall be construed as legal, accounting or other professional advice outside the realm of real estate brokerage.